
As early as 1910, books have been made into movies, but since the late 70’s, a large amount of novels have been turned into movies. As the computer age approached, these books were pushed into the print era with everything else that was trumped. Is this just a profit scheme to make more money on a successful book? The problem that readers have with movie adaptations of books is the lack of authenticity. In my opinion, movie adaptations are just another form of expressing the imagination that was created from reading a specific novel.
One opinion from pussreboots on movie adaptations, “I consider it a good movie adaptation if the film made me want to read (or re-read) the book.”
http://alturl.com/xgn6In contrast to this opinion, Terra Shield comments, “Seriously? The movies kill the books, especially Harry Potter. Unless someone gives me free tickets, I don't think I'd watch them... the books offer so much more.”
http://alturl.com/qxpp
Either way, I think that we can all agree that some books made fabulous movies. Take Roger Allers’
Aladdin, this movie defined a generation of Disney movies for children. Another book that was turned into an immensely significant movie was Bret Easton Ellis’s
American Psycho. Even if you aren’t a horror movie fan, this movie does stick out as a staple of its time.
So why do most people prefer the book to the movie? Wendy Moon has an opinion on this issue, “In trying to understand why people generally seem to prefer the book to the movie version of a story, I came up with this theory: Perhaps we just like best what we knew first. Which, in most cases, is the book. Here's how it goes: you read a book, love it, find out it's been made into a movie, see the movie, and end up disappointed. Of course in reading the book first, you couldn't help but form ideas about how the characters looked. You loved all the little details that didn't make it into the limited time of the movie. And so you come out of the theater or close the dvd box feeling strongly that the book was so much better than the movie.”
http://alturl.com/ozi2
No matter if you prefer the book to the movie, or prefer to read it before or after you watch the movie; my advice is to always strive to read the book
and watch the movie. Two perspectives are always better than one, even if you favor one over the other- that point is inevitable. If you would like to find out more about movie adaptations or want to try to read some books that have been transformed, here are some links:
Guardian’s 50 best movie adaptations
http://alturl.com/k5zeMovie adaptation challenge
http://alturl.com/r8iw